The Zeke Elliott case

As this is written, Ezekiel Elliott, star running back of the Dallas Cowboys, and the National Football League are involved in a spat over a six-game suspension given Elliott for domestic violence involving a former girlfriend, Tiffany Thompson.  The incidents of violence are said to have occurred in July of 2016 in Columbus, Ohio, where Elliott played at Ohio State. Charges were not brought against Elliott in Columbus. Prosecutors there said there were conflicting accounts of what happened. The NFL, however, having botched a couple of previous domestic violence cases, including the infamous case of Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice, on Aug. 11 announced a six-game suspension for Elliott. In the Rice case, the NFL announced a two-game suspension for an incident Rice’s attorneys had described as minor. Later, a video emerged of Rice hitting his then-fiance in the face and knocking her unconscious. NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell acknowledge that he blew the decision in the Rice case and then announced a zero-tolerance policy in which any incidence of domestic violence would bring a six-game suspension.

Elliott has attacked Thompson’s credibility. It has been determined that she lied about one of the incidents in question. Goodell said in his findings that Elliott used physical force against Thompson on three specific occasions. When the six-game suspension was announced it was clear that Elliott would appeal. It went through the proper appeals hearing with the NFL, which of course refused to reduce or eliminate the suspension. Now Elliott and the NFL are in federal court going through the process.  A federal judge in Sherman, Texas, issued an injunction and said that Elliott had not been given a fair hearing by the NFL. The NFL has appealed in the 5th Circuit in New Orleans. And on, and on, and on. There at one point was sports talk radio discussion of being strategic in the appeal. If the Cowboys think this is their year for a Super Bowl run, Elliott should go through the appeal so that he can play. But if the Cowboys think next year might be a better year, Elliott should accept the suspension and miss the first six games when the NFL regular season begins in a few weeks.

I’m a bit turned off by the whole strategic discussion. Why don’t we focus on what’s right and what’s wrong? My personal opinion is that neither Zeke Elliott nor Tiffany Thompson is going to be a candidate for any citizenship awards. The NFL had evidence, likely not reaching criminal legal standards, that Elliott used physical force. If it’s a zero-tolerance policy, that’s it. The case is frequently compared to New England Patriots’ quarterback Tom Brady’s situation in the deflategate case. Brady delayed his two-game suspension by a year and challenged the commissioner’s authority to make such a decision.  The legal question in the Brady case, and perhaps will be also in the Elliott case, was whether the commissioner of the NFL has the power to order such suspensions. The commissioner indeed has such power, as granted by the NFL’s collective bargaining agreement.

The courts ruled in the NFL’s favor in the Brady case, and almost certainly will again in the Elliott case. Elliott has already had a couple of other incidents, including pulling down a young woman’s top to expose her breast while at a St. Patrick’s Day event. A video of that incident is widely circulated. What would be refreshing from Elliott is an acknowledgement of a major mistake in the issues involving Tiffany Thompson and a commitment that it won’t happen again.  Don’t expect that to happen. And I also won’t be surprised if there are other incidents that show what many of us suspect: Zeke Elliott is sadly deficient in basic character.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *